Review of 'Dynamic Covalent Cross-Linked Network Based on A: Synthesis, Properties, and Shape Memory Function'
This article mainly utilizes 'A' as a novel monomer for preparing a dynamic covalent cross-linked network and investigates its mechanical properties, thermal properties, and shape memory function. However, there are some issues with the paper that I suggest be addressed before it can be accepted by the journal. The problems are as follows:
- The author mentions the hardness and toughness of the material in the abstract, but rarely discusses them in the main text.
- It is recommended to use the same name for the same substance in the main text. For example, the author uses both 'methyl tetrahydrophthalic anhydride' and '3a-methyl-5,6-dihydro-4H-isobenzofuran-1,3-dione'. Additionally, MTHPA and MeTHPA are used interchangeably.
- Figure 1 does not appear in the main text or have any explanation.
- The model of the testing instrument used should be specified in the main text.
- It is suggested that the author test the glass transition temperature of the material.
- The content of section 3.2 seems to be incomplete.
- In Figure 6, why does HMY1 require less bending stress under the same bending strain?
- In the conclusion, the last paragraph is in a different font from the preceding text and seems somewhat redundant. It is recommended that the author remove it.
原文地址: https://www.cveoy.top/t/topic/palx 著作权归作者所有。请勿转载和采集!