1. The following provisions are declared as unconstitutional:

a. Section 25(5) of Republic Act No. 11469 or the Bayanihan to Heal as One Act which authorizes the imposition of penalties such as imprisonment and fines for violations of the quarantine measures.

The Supreme Court declared this provision as unconstitutional because it violates the principle of separation of powers. The imposition of penalties is a function of the judiciary, not the executive branch.

b. Section 6(c) of Republic Act No. 11469 which grants the President the power to realign, reprogram, and reallocate appropriations for the government's COVID-19 response.

The Supreme Court declared this provision as unconstitutional because it violates the constitutional provision on the separation of powers and the power of the purse of Congress. The power to appropriate funds belongs to Congress, not the President.

  1. The nine critical questions identified as the core issues and the votes of the magistrates are:

a. Whether or not the Bayanihan to Heal as One Act is constitutional - 12-2 (in favor of constitutionality)

b. Whether or not the President has the power to realign, reprogram, and reallocate appropriations - 14-1 (in favor of unconstitutionality)

c. Whether or not the imposition of penalties for violations of the quarantine measures is constitutional - 13-2 (in favor of unconstitutionality)

d. Whether or not the declaration of a state of national emergency grants the President additional powers - 15-0 (in favor of additional powers)

e. Whether or not the President has the power to take over privately-owned public utilities and businesses affected by the COVID-19 crisis - 15-0 (in favor of power)

f. Whether or not the President has the power to direct the operations of privately-owned hospitals - 15-0 (in favor of power)

g. Whether or not the Bayanihan to Heal as One Act violates the constitutional provisions on due process, equal protection, and non-impairment of contracts - 14-1 (in favor of constitutionality)

h. Whether or not the Bayanihan to Heal as One Act violates the constitutional provision on the non-delegation of legislative power - 14-1 (in favor of constitutionality)

i. Whether or not the Bayanihan to Heal as One Act violates the constitutional provision on the power of Congress to override a presidential veto - 14-1 (in favor of constitutionality)

  1. The matrix of the decisions of each and every magistrate is as follows:

| Justice Name | Provisions Declared as Unconstitutional | Legal Basis | Opinion | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Peralta | Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Separate Concurring | | Caguioa | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Dissenting | | Leonen | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Violation of due process and equal protection | Dissenting | | Carpio | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Violation of due process and equal protection | Dissenting | | Del Castillo | Sec. 25(5) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers | Concurring | | Perlas-Bernabe | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Jardeleza | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Reyes, Jr. | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Gesmundo | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | J. Lopez | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | A. Reyes | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Hernando | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Inting | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Rosario | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring | | Lazaro-Javier | Sec. 25(5) and Sec. 6(c) of RA 11469 | Separation of powers and power of the purse of Congress | Concurring |

Analyze GR No 252578- Atty Howard Calleja et al vs Executive Secretary et al on the following dimensions6 What provisions are declared as unconstitutional-find out the reasons of the reasons for so de

原文地址: https://www.cveoy.top/t/topic/YUE 著作权归作者所有。请勿转载和采集!

免费AI点我,无需注册和登录